One of the most important energy-procurement decisions for a company is whether to choose a fixed price agreed in advance or indexed pricing linked to an exchange quotation. The difference between the two structures lies not simply in the initial price but primarily in how risks are allocated.
In brief: with a fixed price, the trader assumes a significant part of the market-price risk; under an indexed structure, the consumer follows the market and bears both favourable and adverse movements.
What does a fixed price mean?
Under a fixed-price contract, the unit price of energy is set in advance for the period specified in the contract. If expected annual consumption is also known, a substantial part of the energy cost becomes predictable.
The greatest benefit is predictability. A sudden rise in exchange prices is not reflected directly in the contractual energy price. This comes at a cost: the trader normally incorporates procurement and hedging risk into the offer, so in a stable or falling market the fixed price may be higher than the cost of a well-timed indexed structure.
What does an indexed price mean?
Under an indexed contract, the energy price is linked to a specified exchange benchmark. For natural gas this is often the Dutch TTF or another European or regional gas-market quotation; for electricity it is an electricity-market index specified in the contract.
The price payable is typically the benchmark price plus the trader's surcharge, known as the spread. The contract specifies whether settlement uses a daily, monthly or other periodic average, which foreign-exchange rate applies and what other cost components are added.
| Aspect | Fixed price | Indexed price |
|---|---|---|
| Predictability | High | Lower; requires continuous monitoring |
| Impact of market-price movements | Limited during the contractual period | Direct or with a short delay |
| Benefit of falling market prices | Generally not realised | May be realised |
| Risk of rising market prices | Generally borne by the trader | Generally borne by the consumer |
| Foreign-exchange risk | Depends on the structure | Often appears directly |
| Initial price level | May be higher because of the risk premium | May appear more favourable, but is variable |
| Need for active energy management | Lower | Higher |
There are solutions between the two extremes
Several transitional structures can be created between fixed and indexed pricing. These may include fixing part of consumption while indexing the remainder, fixing prices partially at several points in time, or using a structure with a price cap.
For larger consumption volumes, these blended solutions may allow a company to retain predictability for part of its costs while benefiting from a possible decline in market prices.
Important: the current price alone is not sufficient for a decision. The benchmark index, pricing period, spread, exchange rate, quantity tolerance, consumption profile and contractual amendment options must also be examined.
Which structure may be suitable?
A fixed price may be more appropriate when a company operates with a tight budget, places a high value on predictability or does not wish to monitor the energy market continuously.
An indexed price may be more advantageous when the consumer is financially able to manage price volatility, actively follows the market, has a flexible consumption or production profile and accepts that an attractive initial price may change significantly later.
A sound decision is based on a risk strategy
There is no pricing structure that is universally best for every consumer. The right choice depends on consumption volume and timing, the company's liquidity and risk-bearing capacity, and the market situation at the time of the decision.